Dear Literary Journals: Please Send Me an Acceptance Letter for a Belated Birthday Present

Still waiting on submission responses from the final hold out literary journals.

  • Painted Bride Quarterly (date submitted: January 4th; what submitted: 1 fiction, 1 non-fiction)  Official Response Time:  unknown
  • Cicada (date submitted: February 16th; what submitted: 2 poems)  Official Response Time: up to 4 months
  • storySouth (date submitted: June 1st; what submitted: 1 fiction)  Official Response Time: 2-6 months
  • Weave magazine (date submitted:  June 1st; what submitted: 1 non-fiction)  Official Response Time: 3 months

I’m considering contacting PBQ via facebook to ask for a ball park response time figure.  It would help me and all of you out there wondering about the same thing.  Also considering sending another email to Cicada to politely inquire about my poems.  As for storySouth, submishmash has it posted as still “received” (which means nobody has looked at it yet) and Weave magazine is still considering it.  I did get the latest issue of Weave last weekend.  Haven’t started reading yet, but hopefully I can give you a bit of a personal review later this week!

On another personal note:  I went to see Anything Goes with a dear friend on Friday night.  It was, officially, delovely.  Small tip: the theater is designed to offer a good view from any seat, so don’t sweat it out if you buy the cheapest tickets :]


What to Expect While Submitting to the Owl Eye Review and Palooka

I’m a strong believer in simultaneous submissions.  So I’ve had this creative non-fiction short story, “What To Expect While Grieving for Your Father” that I’ve been submitting around multiple places for a month or so.  It’s gotten three rejection letters–from New Delta Review, Owl Eye Review, and Palooka–and today [drum roll please!] I was notified that The Susquehanna Review accepted it!!  (Which meant I needed to withdraw it from consideration at The Sigma Tau Delta Rectangle.  Read here about how NOT to withdraw your materials).

On one note, I’d like to encourage everyone to keep submitting stories they really believe in even if somebody hasn’t liked it (yet).  On another note, I think everyone should bookmark the current issues page at The Susquehanna Review and wait with bated breath for the day that they post the entire new issue online.  Then read my awesome (and rather short, sub 1,000 words) published story.  And then tell me what you think.  On yet another note, (I”m feeling musical here) I’d like to recommend two journals who might love your creative writing, so you should check them out if you’re unfamiliar.

Owl Eye Review

Very new to the publishing scene (2011) means that, in theory, they’re probably a little easier to get accepted to because they don’t have a reputation yet and maybe have a slightly undefined narrative voice.  You can read more about why they were  inspired to found the journal here.

What Owl Eye Review wants:  only poetry and creative non-fiction.  See further submission guidelines.

When they want it:  anytime.  Rolling submissions.

How they want it:  via submishmash.

Allow simultaneous submissions:  yes.

Official submission response time:  none posted.

My personal rejection time: 13 days.

Payment?  No.

Palooka: A Journal of Underdog Excellence

It’s also rather new to the field, but it’s gotten some really excellent peer reviews so I deem it a trustworthy publication.  My personal favorite story in the past issue is Scratch.  The memory of the plot has been haunting me for awhile and I couldn’t remember where I had read it and was really excited just now searching through their archives and stumbling upon it.  Definitely worth more than one read.

What Palooka wants:  pretty much every single kind of creative work possible.

When they want it:  anytime.  Seems to be rolling submissions.

How they want it: via submishmash.

Allow simultaneous submissions: yes.

Official submission response time:  about a week.

My personal submission rejection time:  10 days.

Payment?  One complimentary copy of the issue you were published in plus a discount on additional copies.

Warning:  This is one of the journals that requires a nominal fee–$2.50–for general submissions

So what’s your record amount of rejections for a particular story before an acceptance letter?

Quiz: How to Identify (And Avoid) Submitting Your Creative Writing Under the Influence

It happens late at night.  Well after everyone else has gone to bed, during the witching hour when there’s not even any good reruns on television.  You’ve checked your email and submishmash account 12 times successively in the hopes of an update.  You reread the short story which most recently received rejection from the literary world.  You’re impressed by the performance of each sentence and reassured that the story is damn good.  It deserves to be published.

You google search for literary journals and magazines that might be the perfect home for your short story.  You read their “About” page and are convinced that you MUST submit.  ASAP.

And this is where the dangerous activity starts.

You decide to submit your creative writing right then.  At 3am.  Without reading the contents of the literary journal first.

This is not smart creative writing submission practices.  You might not like waiting for submission responses, and though I can promise you that submitting blinding without doing the research will get you a response letter real quick, without a miracle, it will always be a rejection letter.

But worse than a sense of disappointment over yet another rejection letter, you’ve quite possibly insulted an editor.  If you submit again in the future, your short story might have a hard time getting past that bad first impression.

I’ll admit it.  Hello, I’m Hannah and I have been a reckless creative writing submitter.  [shameful hang of head].  But what’s more embarrassing is that I’ve done it recently.  I should know better.  So I sincerely apologize for cover letters that didn’t follow submission guidelines and submitting short stories that don’t belong in the literary journal in question.  All I can say is that I’m forcing myself to go to be before that sleepy-irrational-dangerous witching hour, and highly recommend that everyone do the same.

[PANK] magazine already has had to deal with my irresponsible creative writing submission.  I encourage you to only submit if you’ve got an awesome short story that they’re actually gong to want to publish.

What they want:  anything and everything.  There are no official guidelines, but there’s definitely a style.

How [PANK] wants it:  via submishmash.

When [PANK] wants it:  anytime.  It’s rolling submissions.

How [PANK] publishes it:  online and print.  Read it!

Official submission response time:  none.

My personal submission response time:  3 days.

Quiz: Are You Submitting Your Creative Writing Under the Influence?

  1. How many issues of the magazine have you read?
  2. Why does your creative writing fit in this particular journal?
  3. Does your creative writing fall within a genre and word count that the journal is actually interested in?

If you answered:

  1. At least one, cover to cover
  2. Because it’s like another particular story, poem, theme, or style previously published in the journal; and
  3. Yes

Then you are safe to submit your creative writing to the journal.  The sooner the better.

BUT.  If you answered any of the questions incorrectly with things like “none,” “because it’s well-written,” and “I don’t know,” then STOP IMMEDIATELY.  Read the journal or magazine and don’t submit until you get all the right answers.

Reexamine your last three creative writing submissions.  Do you pass the quiz, or fail?

A Compressed Response Time at The Journal of Compressed Creative Arts

It’s new.  It’s flashy.  And they’re wicked fast.

I submitted at 1am on Tuesday, May 17th and I got a response by 11am on Thursday, May 19th (it was the good rejection letter I mentioned earlier on this blog).  In the world of literary journals, where the wait ranges from 6 weeks to 6 months, that is an impressive turnaround rate.

Associated with the Rosemont College MFA program, The Journal of Compressed Creative Arts, a strictly online publication, has debuted within the past month and is accepting fiction and non-fiction submissions until August 15th.  They are publishing a favorite submissions on the website every week during that time.  They’ll be accepting poetry later in the year.

The only catch?  Prose has to be sub-600 words and poetry will also have to be extremely compressed.  As they like to phrase it:  “We publish (very) tiny, compressed prose creations of 600 words or less. We use Submishmash for all submissions.  We value form, character, and words that fit to both.  Experimentation is interesting.  Experimentation for the sake of appearing experimental is less interesting.  We like close reading and close writing.  We like to feel what we read before we understand.”

So visit their website to see what kinds of works they’re choosing and get a feel for what you should write, compress, and submit.  Every email they send–even the automated message confirming the receipt–is warm, friendly, and makes you fall in love with this new journal a little more.

If you’re tired of waiting and want to hear some news immediately, submit right now!